Concerned for Iranian's human rights, Cohen applauds Obama in his decision to begin talks with Iran. He insists that only through close contact with the western more civilized world will conditions in Iran improve.
Cohen quotes Iran's seemingly willingness and even eagerness to obtain peace, justice and progress. However even Cohen cannot deny Iran's tendency towards 'Tagieh'. Though Iran belongs to the nuclear nonproliferation treaty, there is still exists a legitimate fear that Iran may use nuclear power to attack other countries, including its neighboring state of Israel. Cohen states that while Iran is member of the nuclear nonproliferation treaty, nuclear-armed Israel is not.
Perhaps Cohen has failed to consider the incredible threat Israel is under. Israel is one of the few sovereign states not part of the NPT. At the very least Israel deserves to be commended on its candidness. As the only democratic country in the Middle East Israel is surrounded by enemies who if supplied with weapons of mass destruction would not hesitate to terminate this small country. It would be irresponsible and even dangerous for Israel to join a pact such as the NPT, for then these countries could choose to demolish Israel without fear of immediate reprieve. Not only would a nuclear attack on Israel murder Israeli citizens, but Israel is so closely adjacent to surrounding hostile countries (including Iran) that the inhabits of these countries would be harmed as well. As the only democratic state in the region, Israel is expected by all the western world to uphold ethics, yet they are criticized when they must take measures to defend themselves and their neighbors (through the possession of nuclear arms).
On the other hand Iran is deceitful, signing the NPT, while simultaneously remaining ambiguous as to their nuclear program. How can a developing country, troubled with turmoil and dissolving in chaos and power hungry leaders, be trusted to control weapons of mass destruction, when they can not even be trusted to control their own government?
Cohen's remark on Israel's resistance to the joining of the NPT is rash and uneducated. An opinion based on biased second hand knowledge, and not on the analysis of actual facts.
Tuesday, September 22, 2009
Monday, September 14, 2009
Health is a right
As the health reformation becomes a Major crisis on America's and the Obama administration's public agenda, Roger Cohen exposes European and American health care coverage. Though long winded, Cohen successfully refutes all opposing opinions- revealing the myths and facts of the health care system in his article "Get Real on Health Care". Cohen convinces the reader of the necessity for health care reform; using statistics to show how for all the money Americans invest into health care, they receive less benefits then "socialized" European countries.
His arguments are supported by quotes from the president of the united states. Adding to his credibility Cohen reflects on has direct experience from both the American and the European health care system, having previously lived in France. Cohen's appeal finds sympathy with many Americans tiered of the stressful search for good coverage. He encourages the public to support Obama's original propasal a plan which intends on insuring all citizens. He also urges Obama to stay true to his polices and not to water them down. Cohen strongly Concludes with the sensible statement that resonates with all, health, Cohen reasons, should be a right available and deserving by all.
His arguments are supported by quotes from the president of the united states. Adding to his credibility Cohen reflects on has direct experience from both the American and the European health care system, having previously lived in France. Cohen's appeal finds sympathy with many Americans tiered of the stressful search for good coverage. He encourages the public to support Obama's original propasal a plan which intends on insuring all citizens. He also urges Obama to stay true to his polices and not to water them down. Cohen strongly Concludes with the sensible statement that resonates with all, health, Cohen reasons, should be a right available and deserving by all.
Sunday, September 13, 2009
self virtus
In his recent article "New tweets, old needs" Cohen comments on the banishment of journalists in Iran, and the resulting use of technology sources such as "Twitter" by Iranian citizens to report their current situations. He discusses within this article the effect that new technologies have had on journalism. The replacement of good journalism is a threat that seems to plague Cohen.Though he believes self proclaimed writers and social networking to be a positive tool of connection he insists reporting will be much compromised if journalism is replaced by such forms.
Cohen comes across pretentious and seemingly self righteous. He dubs himself and others of his profession as elitist- calling attention to the intelligence and organization it takes to be a true journalist; showing the necessities of diction and the importance of bearing wittiness. He Attributes all these characteristics which qualify a good writer to sole rest upon the shoulders of "the journalist".
This piece is a response to Arianna Huffington's criticism of a previous article of Cohen's. Cohen seems to take her rebuff personally and attacks her in turn. He proves to the audience through quoting Huffington, how silly and illogical her statements are and then reexplains his view proving how he is correct. Again, I find Cohen, self absorbed, hungry for praise and seeking redemption. Cohen should learn that sometimes self reflection is more imperative then praise. Not all listeners will concede their opinions with others, a concept Cohen has failed to grasp.
Cohen comes across pretentious and seemingly self righteous. He dubs himself and others of his profession as elitist- calling attention to the intelligence and organization it takes to be a true journalist; showing the necessities of diction and the importance of bearing wittiness. He Attributes all these characteristics which qualify a good writer to sole rest upon the shoulders of "the journalist".
This piece is a response to Arianna Huffington's criticism of a previous article of Cohen's. Cohen seems to take her rebuff personally and attacks her in turn. He proves to the audience through quoting Huffington, how silly and illogical her statements are and then reexplains his view proving how he is correct. Again, I find Cohen, self absorbed, hungry for praise and seeking redemption. Cohen should learn that sometimes self reflection is more imperative then praise. Not all listeners will concede their opinions with others, a concept Cohen has failed to grasp.
Thursday, September 3, 2009
Introduction to Roger Cohen
As this blog will be an analyzer and critique of Roger Cohen's oped pieces in the New York Times, i felt that a little background information on the life of Roger Cohen deemed appropriate.
Roger Cohen was born in London on August 2nd 1955. A graduate of Ballio College at Oxford University, he currently lives with his wife and 4 children in Brooklyn, New York. He is a foreign correspondent, newspaper editor, author, and columnist for the New York Times and the International Herald Tribune.
In his writings Roger Cohen defiantly expresses his political opinions. Though he supported the invasion Cohen criticized Bush's handling of the occupation in Iraq, as well as Obama's lengthy withdrawal plan. He vehemently stands against American military action against Iran and upholds the continuation of negotions. Though Jewish Cohen accuses israel of the "slaying of hundreds of palestinian children." He has been attacked for his beleif that Jews are treated well in Iran.
For his writings Roger Cohn has received numerous awards and honors including the Peter Weitz Prize, the Arthur F. Burns Prize, and the Joe Alex Morris lectureship. He has been nominated twice for the Pultze Prize. Cohen describes himself as "smart, driven, liberal, Jewish".
Roger Cohen was born in London on August 2nd 1955. A graduate of Ballio College at Oxford University, he currently lives with his wife and 4 children in Brooklyn, New York. He is a foreign correspondent, newspaper editor, author, and columnist for the New York Times and the International Herald Tribune.
In his writings Roger Cohen defiantly expresses his political opinions. Though he supported the invasion Cohen criticized Bush's handling of the occupation in Iraq, as well as Obama's lengthy withdrawal plan. He vehemently stands against American military action against Iran and upholds the continuation of negotions. Though Jewish Cohen accuses israel of the "slaying of hundreds of palestinian children." He has been attacked for his beleif that Jews are treated well in Iran.
For his writings Roger Cohn has received numerous awards and honors including the Peter Weitz Prize, the Arthur F. Burns Prize, and the Joe Alex Morris lectureship. He has been nominated twice for the Pultze Prize. Cohen describes himself as "smart, driven, liberal, Jewish".
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)